Creating Livelihoods Through Land Redistribution: Evidence from the One Household - One Hectare Programme in Kokstad

S. Zantsi; S. Mgidi

doi:10.17159/2413-3221/2025/v53n1a17584

Authors

S. Zantsi Economic Analysis Unit, Agricultural Research Council, Hatfield Pretoria https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9787-3913
S. Mgidi Grain Farmers Association of South Africa

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.17159/2413-3221/2025/v53n1a17584

Keywords:

Agricultural Development, Land redistribution, service delivery

Abstract

The South African land redistribution programme has been criticised for solely focusing on redistributing land for commercial farming while ignoring land demand for small-scale farming and settlement. This study reports on implementing the One Household-One Hectare (1HH-1H ) programme in two Kokstad beneficiary villages. The study's first objective was to understand how the programme implementation works on the ground. The other objective was to assess the capacity of the programme to create livelihoods. Our analysis was based on household survey data from 20 beneficiary household heads and two agricultural advisors. The data was analysed using descriptive statistics. Findings show that the programme implementation was need-based and was a joint effort by various government departments. The implementation led to a village setup, where each beneficiary household has a residential area for buildings, kraals and a garden in their one-hectare plot. The remainder of the land was shared as grazing common and forest, while the other arable land was used for cooperative farming and individual arable field lands. In general, beneficiaries were content with the programme’s implementation and reported a significant increase in their livestock herd and crop outputs. Additionally, beneficiaries now enjoy access to clean drinking water, irrigation water, and primary healthcare, among other benefits.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

ALIBER, M., 2019a. How can we promote a range of livelihood opportunities through land redistribution? Working paper 58, Institute for Poverty, Land and Agrarian Studies (PLAAS). Cape Town: University of the Western Cape.

ALIBER, M., 2019b. Forms of agricultural support and the “culture of dependency and entitlement”. Agrekon., 58(2): 141-153.

ALIBER, M., MABHERA, S. & CHIKWANHA, T., 2018. Agrarian reform and rural development. Alice: University of Fort Hare.

ALIBER, M. & COUSINS, B., 2013. Livelihoods after land reform in South Africa. J. Agrar. Change., 13(1): 140–165.

ALIBER, M., REITZES, M. & ROEFS, M., 2006. Assessing the alignment of South Africa’s land reform policy to people’s aspirations and expectations: a policy-oriented report based on a survey in three provinces. Research report. Pretoria: Human Sciences Research Council.

BEINART, W., MNWANA, S. & WOTSHELA, L., 2020. Land reform, rural inequality and agrarian change: the case of Isidenge, Stutterheim, Eastern Cape. Transformation: Critical Perspectives on Southern Africa, 102: 27-48.

BINSWANGER-MKHIZE, H.P., 2014. From failure to success in South African land reform. Afr. J. Agric. Resour. Econom., 9(4): 253–69.

BONTI-ANKOMAH, S., 2001. The social benefits of land redistribution in South Africa—case studies. Agrekon., 40(1): 76-86.

BRADSTOCK, A., 2006. Land reform and livelihoods in South Africa’s Northern Cape province. Land Use Policy., 23: 247–259.

CHAMBERS, R., 1994. The Origins and Practice of Participatory Rural Appraisal. World Develop., 22(7): 953-969.

COUSINS, B., 2013. Land redistribution, populism, and elite capture: New land reform policy proposals under the microscope. Available from http://hsf.org.za/resourcecentre/focus/focus-70-on-focus/focus-70-oct-b-cousins.pdf/view

CONRADIE, B., 2019. Land use and redistribution in the arid west: The case of Laingsburg Magisterial District. Agrekon., 58(3): 281-291.

DE WET, C., 1995. Moving together. Drifting apart: Betterment planning and villagisation in a South African homeland. Johannesburg: Witwatersrand University Press.

HALL, R., 2010. Reconciling the Past, Present, Future: The Parameters and Practices of Land Restitution in South Africa. In C. Walker, A. Bohlin, R. Hall & T. Kepe (eds.), Land, Memory, Reconstruction and Justice: Perspectives on Land Claims in South Africa. Ohio University Press, pp. 17-40.

HART, T.G.B., 2012. How rural land reform policy translates into benefits. Develop. Southern Africa., 29(4): 563-573.

HEBINCK, P., SMITH, L. & ALIBER, M., 2023. Beyond technocracy: The role of the state in rural development in the Eastern Cape, South Africa. Land Use Policy., 126(2023): 106527.

KEPE, T. & HALL, R., 2016. Land redistribution in South Africa. Commissioned report for High-Level Panel on the assessment of key legislation and the acceleration of fundamental change, an initiative of the Parliament of South Africa.

KIRSTEN, J.F., MACHETHE, C.L., NDLOVU, T. & LUBAMBO, P., 2016. Performance of land reform projects in the North West Province of South Africa: Changes over time and possible causes. Develop. Southern Africa., 33(4): 442–58.

MALOPE, P. & BATISANI, N., 2008. Land reforms that exclude the poor: The case of Botswana. Develop. Southern Africa., 25(4): 383-397.

MAMABOLO. M., CHAMINUKA, P. & MACHETHE C., 2022. Temporal and spatial variation of income diversification strategies among rural households in South Africa. Develop. Southern Africa., 39(3): 372-387.

MARCUS, T., EALES, K. & WILDSCHUT, A., 1996. Down to earth: Land demand in the new South Africa. Durban: Indicator Press.

MTERO, F., GUMEDE, N. & RAMANTSIMA, K., 2019. Elite capture in land redistribution in South Africa. Research report No.55. Bellville, University of the Western Cape: Institute for Poverty, Land and Agrarian Studies.

NATIONAL PLANNING COMMISSION [NPC]., 2012. An integrated and inclusive rural economy. Chapter Six of the National Development Plan 2030.

LIEBENBERG, F., 2013. South African agricultural production, productivity and research performance in the 20th Century. Doctoral thesis, University of Pretoria, Pretoria.

LONG, N., 2001. Development Sociology: Actor Perspectives. London: Routledge.

LAND REFORM AND AGRICULTURE ADVISORY PANEL [LRAAP ]., 2019. Final report of the presidential advisory panel on land reform and agriculture. Pretoria: The Presidency.

PUTTERGILL, C., BOMELA, N., GROBBELAAR, J. & MOGUERANE, K., 2011. The limits of land restitution: Livelihoods in three rural communities in South Africa. Develop. Southern Africa., 28(5): 597-611.

RAMAPHOSA, C., 2018. Land reform in South Africa is crucial for inclusive growth.

RYAN, J., 2017. Examining land reform in South Africa: Evidence from survey data. Doctoral dissertation, University of Cape Town.

RUSENGA, C., 2019. The agribusiness model in South African land reform? Land Use implications for the land reform beneficiaries. Agrarian South: J. Political Econ., 8(3): 440–461.

RUSENGA, C., 2020. Setting them up to fail: Enforcement of the agribusiness model on land reform projects in South Africa. Rev. Afr. Political Econ., 47(165): 382-398.

STATISTICS SOUTH AFRICA [STATSSA]., 2011. Population census. Pretoria: South African government.

SHARAUNGA, S. & MUDHARA, M., 2021. Analysis of livelihood strategies for reducing poverty among rural women’s households: a case study of KwaZulu‐Natal, South Africa. J. Int. Dev., 33: 127–150.

SHOPANE, G., 2017. One Household, One Hectare programme on track. Available from https://www.vukuzenzele.gov.za/one-household-one-hectare-programme-track

VINK, N. & KIRSTEN, J., 2019. Principles and practice for successful farmland redistribution in South Africa. Working Paper No. 57. University of the Western Cape, Cape Town, South Africa: Programme for Land and Agrarian Studies.

XABA, B.M., 2020. South African land question and the dilemma of land expropriation without compensation: A critical examination. In A.O. Akinola, K. Kaseeram & N.N. Jili (eds.), The new political economy of land reform in South Africa. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.

ZANTSI, S., MACK, G. & MANN, S., 2020. Cultural innovation, aspirations and success among smallholders in former homelands of the Eastern Cape Province of South Africa: Theory and evidence. Int. J. Soc. Econ., 47(3): 404–422.

ZANTSI, S. & GREYLING, J.C., 2021. Land redistribution in South Africa’s land reform policy: A better way to select beneficiaries. Agrekon., 60(2): 108-127.

ZANTSI, S., MACK, G. & VINK, N., 2021. Towards a viable farm size – determining a viable farm household income for emerging farmers in South Africa’s land redistribution programme: An income aspiration approach. Agrekon., 60(2): 91-107.

ZANTSI, S., MAZWANE, S. & GREYLING, J.C., 2022. Determinants of potential land reform beneficiaries’ willingness to relocate from their former homeland homestead farms to commercial farms. S. Afr. Geogr. J., 104(2): 213-230.